Updated May 2020 By Consultant Dietitian Kirsten Jackson
Fasting and more specifically, intermittent fasting has become popular with many in recent years. It has many controversially claimed benefits and now there are some claims that the practise is beneficial for irritable bowel syndrome.
In this post, I am going to look at the science behind the idea that fasting is good for IBS.
Table of Contents
You only have to google ‘fasting for IBS’ and thousands of websites pop up. There are many individuals claiming that fasting for various lengths of time has solved their IBS through ‘resting’ and ‘healing’ their gut.
Despite the many claims, online articles often start discussing the benefits of intermittent fasting on weight loss and metabolism which is irrelevant. Some also reference mice or rat studies, again not relevant to a human population.
The claims are interesting considering as in ‘first line’ practise we generally recommend regular eating, with irregular eating / skipping meals being seen as a cause or aggravation of IBS (1).
The Migrating Motor Complex
The migrating motor complex or MMC is the element of IBS where claims around fasting being beneficial have come from.
The MMC are a set of electrical waves which work on the digestive system during periods of fasting e.g. overnight / between meals.
Their main role is to push indigestible (things that your body can not digest) substances through our gut, right to the end. Substances such as bone, fibre and bad bacteria come into this category.
These electrical waves happen approx every 90 minutes between meals and are the cause of your stomach rumbling (2).
MMC in IBS
The MMC does not work properly in those with IBS (3). This leads to ‘dysmotility’ in the small bowel, which means the movement of substances through your small bowel is not working correctly (4).
Some individuals claim that having more gaps between eating allows the MMC to work more effectively and thus, improves IBS symptoms. Although this theory sounds great, there is currently no scientific evidence to support this idea.
In terms of improving MMC function and clearing the small bowel of bacteria, what we do know is that antibiotics may help. In patients who have IBS and small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, dysmotility (when the gut doesn’t move things through correctly) is improved with targeting bacterial overgrowth (5).
Fasting In IBS
There is only 1 cross-sectional study looking at the effect of fasting in IBS and this was done in Japan in 2007 (6).
In this study, participants had 4 weeks of psychotherapy and medications (the ‘standard’ therapy), then went on to fast for a further 4 weeks. Whilst they were fasting, they were given 1-2 L of fluid each day, along with some nutrition through their veins.
After 4 weeks of fasting, the participants were fed slowly, starting at 250 calories per day.
The study showed that those who fasted, had improvements in pain, discomfort, abdominal distension, diarrhoea, anorexia, nausea and anxiety. They also showed an improvement in quality of life. These improvements were better than those who had just had the ‘standard’ treatment.
Although this study looks promising, there are quite a few problems with using the results in real life.
- The fasting period was 4 weeks, which is not safe outside of that hospital environment where alternative IV nutrition was given. To have this nutrition treatment for IBS is also not ethical as it runs its own risks and is therefore only used normally when the digestive system is not working at all e.g. in digestive surgery.
- We don’t know what the diet was given after the 4 week fasting period. It may well have been a low FODMAP diet.
- The study is only 12 weeks long which does not prove that fasting provides long-term benefits.
Usually meal patterns and regular eating are in ‘first line’ advice for IBS, which means it is one of the first things that those with IBS are advised on.
Unfortunately, when we look at studies around regular eating, there are few that just look at this element on its own. It is therefore difficult to pin-point how effective eating regularly is for IBS symptoms.
The studies that we do have which include regular eating alongside looking at other ‘first line’ advice such as fibre, fluid and meal sizes show an improvement in IBS symptoms (7).
One cross-sectional study including 966 IBS patients showed women who do not eat regularly are 30% more likely to have IBS. Not eating regularly was also linked with increased pain and worsening of symptoms in IBS (8).
Why Are There So Many Claims Around Fasting In IBS?
Despite there being no scientific evidence for fasting in IBS, there are quite a few people claiming to have got symptom relief. So why is this?
Well, we don’t know yet. But, here are a few potential explanations;
- Reduced stress levels in individuals knowing that symptoms will not flare up because they have not eaten.
- Reduced portion sizes – as the stomach size shrinks with lack of food – in comparison to large portions previously.
- The individuals’ diet was previously high in FODMAPs which were aggravating symptoms.
- The individuals’ diet previously contained an allergen which the individual was reacting to.
Are There Any Risks With Fasting For Those With IBS?
Again, there are no direct, long-term studies looking at fasting in IBS so it is hard to say. But, there are quite a few concerns.
Firstly, fasting (especially without dietitian supervision) may lead to a reduced intake of certain dietary components leaving an individual at risk of nutritional deficiencies. Secondly, other gut-specific food components such as prebiotics and fibre will likely be reduced, which could harm the levels of good gut bacteria. In-tern, this may worsen IBS in the long-term.
Take Home Message
- There is currently no evidence to support fasting for IBS.
- Fasting or irregular meals may worsen symptoms of IBS.
- Do not skip the ‘first-line’ advice which has been proven to benefit IBS symptoms e.g. stress management, fibre, fluid, exercise and regular meals.
- See a dietitian if you require individual IBS relief support.
Kirsten Jackson is a UK registered Consultant Gastroenterology Dietitian and founder of The Food Treatment Clinic. She has undergone many qualifications to get where she is today, including a UK BSc Honours Degree in Dietetics and Post-Graduate Certificate in Advanced Dietetics. In addition to this, she has FODMAP Training from Kings College London University. Kirsten set up The Food Treatment Clinic in 2015 after first experiencing digestive problems herself. She felt that the NHS was unable to provide the support individuals needed and went on to specialise in this area before opening a bespoke IBS service. Kirsten also participates in charity work as an Expert Advisor for the IBS Network. In addition, she can be seen in publications such as Cosmopolitan and The Telegraph discussing IBS as an Official Media Spokesperson to the IBS Network.
There is scientific evidence that fasting improves IBS https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17078771
Kirsten Jackson Specialist Dietitian says
Hi La, thank you for sharing! Unfortunately, this study isn’t classed as good quality enough to provide advice on.
The reason being is that it is only 15 days long and the IBS sufferers had to fast for 10 days first. So my questions would be
1. How can we take this in to practise?
2. Would we advise people to starve for 10 days of every 15? Because this is all that was looked at and even then I wouldn’t know if this will help long-term.
3. How would this affect someone’s health if used as a long-term therapy? I would also be seriously concerned over the lack of nutritional intake if this was used longer-term. My final concern would be the link between IBS and eating disorders. Using extreme restrictions can be a trigger.
So while this study is interesting, until more practical and safe studies are done, the results do not tell us anything unfortunately.